When I saw the display in Walgreens, I decided on the shade Berry Soft. It costs around $4.
These come in pretty similar packaging as the original Baby Lips, but all of the tubes in the Dr. Rescue line are white and slightly fatter. Most people probably don't notice that these are slightly thicker, but I have my old Baby lips in a lipstick holder, and these new ones don't fit.
The shade is a very natural pink/berry shade. It seems like these have a little less pigmentation than the originals as well. Here is a swatch of this shade:
Maybelline claims that this gives 12hr hydration, and I don't really know about that.That claim seems a little exaggerated, but it is definitely very moisturizing! The only issue I ever had with the original Baby Lips is I felt like they could be a little more moisturizing, and this is exactly the moisture I was looking for. This also has a menthol smell and a cooling sensation on the lips. I find it very soothing!
To summarize, these feel better on the lips than the original Baby Lips, and the moisturization lasts longer. I love to put this on at night, and in the morning I wake up with softer lips. These are also slightly more expensive than the other Baby Lips (around $1 more). I can't really decide if I like the Dr. Rescue line better than the Original and Electro because the colors in this line seem a little more sheer. I think I like all the lines equally, but for different reasons. I really enjoy this product though, and I would repurchase it.